booksiloved.com - Book reviews of books the reviewer really liked

A review of Our Band Could Be Your Life Scenes from the American Indie Underground 1981-1991

by Michael Azerrad

Picking up where "England's Dreaming" left off, this book profiles the independent underground bands of the 80s.

Reviewed by: Michelle Miller Detwiler
About Michelle Miller Detwiler

Our Band Could Be Your Life If punk was the definitive end to the "love generation," the music that sprang from it was the antithesis of the "greed is good" '80s'. In "Our Band Could Be Your Life," by music writer Michael Azerrad, is a snapshot at some of the bands which did not follow the rules of what major record labels were looking for at the time. Instead, they had to turn to their own resources, starting their own and recording for small independent labels, yet for the majority of the bands Azerrad interviewed, still continue to maintain cult followings and are some of the most well-respected bands in the music industry.

Beginning with Black Flag, the first band to really rise from the ashes of punk rock to spearhead the hard-core movement, Azerrad gets the straight scoop from the band members themselves. From the tragic demise of the Minutemen's D. Boon to the beginnings of the straight-edge movement by Minor Threat, which continued on in a more subtle way with Fugazi, as well as the unlikely pairings and clamorous, yet emotional, music of Hüsker Dü, the frustrating struggles of the independent band is detailed no-holds barred. These bands existed at a time before major labels bought indies, before Sub Pop was "home to Nirvana," and when wearing an SST or Dischord T-shirt meant you were a "freak." The Do-It-Yourself aesthetic of these bands earned them little money, but tons of respect, from critics, their peers and their fans.

"Our Band ..." gives a glimpse into the animosity between bandmates, especially those in the Replacements and the near-legendary catfights between Dinosaur Jr's Lou Barlow and J Mascis. But it also shows the staying power of experimental band Sonic Youth, which found success (and retained respect) on a major label years after years on independents. The book also delves into the period right before and up to the grunge way of the early '90s', with the one-hit wonder success of long-time indie trawlers, the Butthole Surfers, as well as Mudhoney's almost-there-but-not-quite ride on the grunge wave.

Mission of Burma, Big Black and the explosion Steve Albini made in the realm of music producer, and "twee-rockers" Beat Happening also have their own chapters in the book. This book will dispel the myths for anyone who missed the important post-punk bands, for anyone who thought grunge was a revolutionary music style, and for anyone who thinks that only major label, charting bands are worth listening to.

Click here to buy this book, or read more about it at Amazon.com: Our Band Could Be Your Life

Copyright © by Michelle Miller Detwiler, 2002

Reviewed by Michelle Miller Detwiler:
-- And I Don't Want To Live This Life - by Deborah Spungen
-- A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius - by Dave Eggers
-- England's Dreaming - by Jon Savage
-- I'm With the Band - by Pamela Des Barres
-- Our Band Could Be Your Life - by Michael Azerrad
-- Maus: A Survivor's Tale - by Art Spiegelman
-- Psychotic Reactions and Carburetor Dung - by Lester Bangs
-- Healing Digestive Disorders - by Andrew Gaeddert
-- U2 At the End of the World - by Bill Flanagan









Home ------- All the Reviews